Climate Diversity is Our Strength: Responding to Wynes and Nicholas (2019)
[Version 2. To fix a typo in the original] What happens to a society when children become nothing more than a carbon footprint to be avoided? Should this concept be taught in schools? Researchers Wynes and Nicholas (2019) did a survey of climate change curricula in secondary schools in Canada. In their opinion the schools are not doing a good enough job of 'convincing' students of the 'scope and urgency' of climate change, or that 'expert agree'. They were disconcerted to find that Friends of Science materials were even referred to in some school curricula, showing examples of the 'polarized' debate on climate, which Wynes and Nicholas say does not exist. Michelle Stirling wrote a rebuttal paper that shows that not all experts agree and that Wynes and Nicholas are advocating for pink slips for teachers and humanicide for Canadians. Their previous research that suggested having one less child would 'save the planet' - particularly sad this is their view when the real polluters and emitters are things like container ships and developing nations. Container ships: Container Ship - How to reduce effect on Climate and Pollution Developing Nations: https://blog.friendsofscience.org/2019/05/05/futile-folly-canadas-climate-policy-goals-in-the-global-context/ Stirling's paper: Climate Diversity is Our Strength: Responding to Wynes and Nicholas (2019) by Michelle Stirling :: SSRN ... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rXYyCWX2uYY
Dr. Clark was featured in the Mathew Embry award-winning documentary "Global Warning" wherein he takes the well-known climate activist, Catherine Abreu, on a tour of his lab and they square off on climate. Abreu is listed as one of the 100 most influential people on climate, according to Apolitical, and she is shown in the film, meeting directly with Canada's climate negotiators for the Conference of the Parties (COP) climate events. However, Dr. Clark explains that while she is an elegant woman and eloquent on her topic, she was not very interested in the actual science he tried to present to her. Watch Dr. Clark's full presentation on our main website: Friends of Science Twentieth Annual Event, With Dr. Ian Clark and Robert Lyman | Friends of Science
https://friendsofscience.org/library/events/friends-of-science-twentieth-annual-event,-with-dr.-ian-clark-and-robert-lyman.html
...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=740vWEE5bJ8
Climate scientist Dr. Madhav Khandekar discusses how cold snaps and heavy winter shows suggest a solar minimum is affecting climate. Cooling temperatures, erratic weather and much precipitation were associated with the solar minumum of the Little Ice Age (1300-1860). See Brian Fagan's book "The Little Ice Age: How Climate Changed History" or the History Channel documentary for more information on that time. Climate scientist Dr. Madhav Khandekar is a former Environment Canada research scientist, past IPCC expert reviewer, WMO regional expert, long-term member of CMOS - Canadian Meteorological and Oceanographic Society.
...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z_q-Vb4580o
A short take on the problems of an intertied grid of renewables when there is a regional 'dunkelflaute' (days long loss of wind) - with Dr. Benny Peiser of the Global Warming Policy Foundation of the UK. To see Dr. Peiser's full presentation on "Europe's NetZero Rebellion and the implications for Canada, go to our "Past Events" page: https://friendsofscience.org/library/events/benny-peiser-europe-net-zero-rebellion.html
...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZoVt3oYm8es
The Uncertainty Has Settled, Edmonton / Canada (Audience feedback). Camera and interviews: Sheila Gunn Reid / Rebel Media. The people want open, civil debate on #climate and #energy policies.
...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QEqwNBHjz-E
Independent Dutch filmmaker Marijn Peols talks about the real problems that those who truly want to save the planet could address - simply restoring the degraded soil around the world to qualitative arable land would cost little, would increase natural CO2 absorption and would give local populations a better means of healthy food and potential access to economic markets. The cost would be minimal. As Poels' points out in other video clips in this series, one does best by providing support for local people in developing nations. So much of the Western focus is on building windmills and solar farms where the energy can't be stored, or biogas where the monocrops degrade the soil and increase food insecurity, yet the real riches lie in arable land and revitalised soil. Watch Marijn's self-financed movie "The Uncertainty Has Settled" - rent it on VIMEO: https://vimeo.com/ondemand/theuncertaintyhassettled
...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HU0sGgM9III
Spring flooding is a seasonal phenomenon across most of the Northern Hemisphere, sometimes leading to catastrophic flooding depending on the depth of snowpack and the rate of melting, or combinations of that and regional precipitation. But extreme floods are not evidence of climate change, despite being presented as such by the media. "Climate Change" refers to long periods of time (30, 50, 100, 1,000 year cycles) with statistically significant trends of weather patterns - individual extreme events are not climate change. Roger Pielke, Jr. has studied climate policy and extreme weather events for over 25 years, consulting to the insurance industry. He has done a number of plain language reviews of recent IPCC reports, showing that despite press release headlines like "Code Red for Humanity" or "axis of human suffering", the evidence shows there are no trends to more extreme events. Friends of Science Society has a full presentation by Dr. Madhav Khandekar on extreme weather vs climate change on our YouTube channel and event page, as well as a series of short clips with Dr. Khandekar. Dr. Khandekar stresses that adaptation is the key to addressing extreme weather events and climate change. Be prepared! Spring flooding happens almost every spring!
...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wx50Gj5ShJ4
Climate Plan and Coal Phase-Out Implications: Understanding Social Costs of Carbon. This is the full presentation that was given to the Agricultural Services Board in Grande Prairie on Jan. 17, 2018.
"Climate plans center around reduction of carbon dioxide emissions. Coal is a large emitter of carbon dioxide, but in Alberta, provides more than 50% of power generation and is the cheapest form of power. Carbon taxes are calculated based on assumed future damages. These economic calculations are tied to climate models (simulations) - but climate models have over-exaggerated projections of global warming. Working with materials of economist Dr. Ross McKitrick, we discuss the methods and implications of the climate plan and coal phase-out."
CBC and the Government of Alberta considered this to be controversial.
http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/edmonton/friends-of-science-agricultural-service-board-conference-grande-prairie-michelle-stirling-1.4494032
Additional resources:
McKitrick on Climate Change https://www.friendsofscience.org/assets/documents/McKitrick_Climate_Change_SCC_Feb_14_2015.pdf
McKitrick on Climate Change videos https://youtu.be/g30JfQIK6GA
Dire Consequences - Destroying Alberta's Affordable Power Advantage http://blog.friendsofscience.org/2016/09/29/dire-consequences-destroying-albertas-affordable-power-advantage/
Alberta's Climate Plan - a Burden with No Benefit https://friendsofscience.org/assets/documents/AB_Climate%20Plan_Economic_Impact_Gregory_Tech.pdf (Technical)
...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MWL6-nm1g_U
Friends of Science 8th Annual Luncheon with Dr. Ian Plimer, Professor of Geology, University of Adelaide, Australia, May 16, 2011 at Calgary, Alberta. Part 1.
...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sAXnLRPelA8
Canada's CBC-TV loves to tell people that climate change is seen 'in your backyard.' This is absurd, since climate change is measured over 30, 50, 100 and millennial time scales But what happens when a family of tiny Panda's goes for a walk and they DO find 'climate change' in their back yard?? Enjoy this light-hearted and optimistic look at climate change with your children or grandchildren. Life is beautiful. Children should be busy having fun, not being turned into angry school-skipping activists, trying to 'save the planet' from the magnificent modern world built by their parents' years of hard work. education, and earned wisdom. The Sun drives climate change, directly and indirectly, interacting in a dynamic, chaotic manner with the internal variabilities of Earth's natural systems, and greater forces in the universe (like cosmic rays, orbital patterns of planets, and more!). Check out: https://climatechange101.ca/
...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QPFq0GCsLTA