In this episode of Mentally Unscripted, Paul and Scott discuss using disconfirming evidence and falsifiability to overcome confirmation bias.
Resources:
[Confirmation Bias: Why Your Decisions Suck, and You Fight With Your Friends](
https://strengthandreason.com/confirmation-bias)
[Use Disconfirming Evidence to Make Your Decisions Suck Less](
https://strengthandreason.com/disc-evi)
Judgment in Managerial Decision Making
Probabilistic Thinking
Top Takeaways:
1. Humans tend to look only for confirming evidence. But often, we need disconfirming evidence to find the correct solution to a question.
2. Disconfirming evidence is better to use when examining a belief because it uses deductive logic instead of inductive logic.
3. Understanding the risk posed by COVID is complicated by the lack of unfiltered, scientific data that gives a level-headed view of the situation.
Timestamps:
[0:00] Discussion of Idiocracy – is it fiction or a documentary?
[4:42] What is confirming and disconfirming evidence?
[7:07] A study demonstrating the value of disconfirming evidence.
[10:56] People tend to avoid using disconfirming evidence because it takes more resources than seeking out confirming information.
[13:08] Falsifiability, the problem of induction, and deductive reasoning.
[18:03] Unfalsifiable claims may still be true. We just can’t falsify them.
[21:18] Applying disconfirming evidence and falsifiability to COVID.
[21:32] The debate over using masks to protect against COVID’s spread
[25:32] One factor complicating an analysis is that people aren’t good at assessing risk.
[28:35] Statistics are unreliable because they are difficult to measure and driven by incentives other than public health.
[35:05] As a population, we need to ask better questions and be literate in the concept of falsifiability.
Catch the full episode at Mentally Unscripted [Ep31 - Disconfirming Evidence and Falsifiability: The Two Most Powerful Mental Tools You’re Not Using]( https:// bit.ly/disconfirm)
Follow our hosts on Twitter.
[Scott](
https://twitter.com/StrengthReason)
[Paul](
https://twitter.com/ThoughtMachina)
Follow Scott at [Strength and Reason](
https://strengthandreason.com)
For all our episodes, go to [Mentally Unscripted](
https://mentallyunscripted.com)
Subscribe on
[Apple Podcasts](
https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/id1548381924)
[Spotify](
https://open.spotify.com/show/4LCJ0RNcSJPet9BnMeHykP)
[Google Podcasts](
https://podcasts.google.com/feed/aHR0cHM6Ly9mZWVkcy5idXp6c3Byb3V0LmNvbS8xNTMyMzgzLnJzcw==)
[Amazon](
https://music.amazon.com/podcasts/8b4a224e-11e9-4d80-bc02-26fbf1964eb8/Mentally-Unscripted)