LBRY Block Explorer

LBRY Claims • 167535

415209658602807ba77411a1b1e32eae2a59a40f

Published By
Created On
17 Oct 2020 07:05:46 UTC
Transaction ID
Cost
Safe for Work
Free
Yes
Merit, Meaning, and Human Bondage: An Essay on Free Will
Author: Nomy Arpaly
Perhaps everything we think, feel, and do is determined, and humans--like stones or clouds--are slaves to the laws of nature. Would that be a terrible state? Philosophers who take the incompatibilist position think so, arguing that a deterministic world would be one without moral responsibility and perhaps without true love, meaningful art, and real rationality. But compatibilists and semicompatibilists argue that determinism need not worry us. As long as our actions stem, in an appropriate way, from us, or respond in some way to reasons, our actions are meaningful and can be judged on their moral (or other) merit. In this highly original work, Nomy Arpaly argues that a deterministic world does not preclude moral responsibility, rationality, and love--in short, meaningful lives--but that there would still be something lamentable about a deterministic world. A person may respond well to reasons, and her actions may faithfully reflect her true self or values, but she may still feel that she is not free. Arpaly argues that compatibilists and semicompatibilists are wrong to dismiss this feeling--for which there are no philosophical consolations--as philosophically irrelevant. On the way to this bittersweet conclusion, Arpaly sets forth surprising theories about acting for reasons, the widely accepted idea that ought implies can, moral blame, and more.
Author
Content Type
Nomy Arpaly
application/pdf
Language
English
Open in LBRY

More from the publisher

Controlling
THE F
Controlling
COLLE
Controlling
NEGAT
Controlling
LEAKS
Controlling
REVOL
Controlling
EMILY
Controlling
RICHA
Controlling
KITWA
Controlling
DANGE